Why Yelling at Your Dog Does More Harm Than Good

As dog parents, we’ve all had moments of frustration when our furry friends just don’t seem to listen. It can be tempting to raise our voices in these instances, but is this really the best way to communicate?

The Short Answer

Yelling at your dog is not considered physical abuse, but it can have negative effects on their mental well-being and overall relationship with you. It’s an unhealthy form of communication that can cause fear, anxiety, and stress in your pet.

So let’s explore the world from our dog’s perspective and why a different, more compassionate communication approach may be the key to a happy and obedient pup.

Key highlights:

  • Yelling can be threatening to dogs and may worsen their poor behavior.
  • Regular yelling can induce chronic stress and trauma in dogs.
  • Treats and praises, i.e., positive reinforcement, are healthier and more effective for training.
  • Emotional abuse in dogs can cause behavioral shifts, changes in eating, and increased anxiety.

brown puppy lying on papers next to bowl

How Do Dogs Perceive Yelling?

When we yell, our dogs don’t understand the context like a human would. Instead, they perceive loud noises and angry tones as something threatening and scary.

Imagine if someone towered over you, shouting in a language you couldn’t understand – intimidating, right? That’s likely how your dog feels.

Dogs are inherently social creatures. They’ve evolved to understand and respond to cues from humans, including our tone of voice. However, dogs are not adept at discerning the nuances of human language. They focus more on the tone and volume of our voices rather than the specific words being said.

When we yell, dogs are likely to perceive it as a sign of aggression or danger rather than a call for behavioral correction.

Thus, yelling could actually worsen behavioral issues as it can create anxiety and fear in your dog, which in turn can lead to more problematic behaviors.

Remember, in the world of dogs, communication is often more about tone and body language, and less about the volume of your voice. Understanding this can lead to more harmonious coexistence with our furry friends.

Can Yelling Traumatize Your Dog?

While your dog might not remember the specifics of you yelling at them, they will remember how it made them feel.

Yelling can indeed be traumatizing to dogs, especially when it’s a recurring event. Dogs are emotionally intelligent creatures, capable of feeling a range of emotions, including fear, anxiety, and stress. These emotions can emerge when they’re exposed to loud, angry voices.

In fact, research has shown that dogs living in stressful or inconsistent environments are more likely to develop behavioral problems. When subjected to repeated yelling, a dog may start to display signs of stress such as excessive barking, chewing, or even aggression, which is essentially their way of communicating their discomfort.

It’s important to understand that while an occasional raised voice might not cause lasting harm, frequent and intense yelling can lead to a state of chronic stress in dogs, affecting their health and well-being in the long run.

person's hand touching white and black puppy

Why Positive Reinforcement Is Better

Positive reinforcement training is a better alternative to yelling, and it’s recommended by dog behaviorists and trainers worldwide.

This approach involves rewarding your dog for good behavior, which encourages them to repeat it. For example, when your dog obeys a command, you can reward them with treats, praises, or belly rubs.

Positive reinforcement is all about creating a favorable association with good behavior, and this method tends to yield more consistent and happier outcomes.

My pup’s experience…
I remember a time when my own dog, Sam, was having a hard time learning to “stay”. The traditional approach of commanding sternly wasn’t working, and I noticed how stressed he became when my voice raised.

So, I shifted to a positive reinforcement approach, rewarding Sam with his favorite chicken-flavored treat whenever he successfully followed the “stay” command. His progress was remarkable. Not only did he start responding to “stay” more often, but he also seemed more eager and happy during training sessions.

This is an example of how positive reinforcement can work wonders in training dogs. By creating a positive environment and understanding that dogs learn differently than humans, we can better our relationships with our canine companions and create an atmosphere of mutual respect and trust.

Here’s a Table Comparing Effects of Yelling vs. Positive Reinforcement:

Yelling at DogsPositive Reinforcement
PerceptionThreatening, scaryEncouraging, motivating
Effect on BehaviorIncreases anxiety and stress, may worsen bad behaviorsReinforces good behaviors, promotes learning
Long-term ImpactCan lead to chronic stress, fear, and health problemsLeads to more consistent outcomes, healthier relationship

Spotting Emotional Abuse in Dogs

Recognizing emotional abuse in dogs can be challenging, as signs can be subtle and easily overlooked.

Consistent negative changes in your dog’s behavior, such as cowering, excessive panting, aggression, or avoidance behaviors, can be red flags.

Furthermore, if your dog suddenly starts to have accidents in the house or seems overly clingy or withdrawn, these could be signs of emotional distress.

One often overlooked sign is a change in eating habits. Dogs under stress may lose their appetite or start eating rapidly, which can lead to health issues. Look out for unusual weight loss or gain, as well as drastic changes in water consumption.

These changes often reflect your dog’s emotional well-being and should not be ignored.

Remember, just as with humans, every dog is different. Building a deep, trusting relationship with your dog involves understanding their unique behaviors and responses. If your dog exhibits any unusual behaviors, it might be worth consulting a vet or a certified dog behaviorist. They can provide guidance and rule out any medical issues that may be causing such changes.


How can I correct my dog without yelling?

Instead of yelling, use a calm and firm voice to issue commands. Reinforce good behaviors with rewards like treats, praise, or playtime, which helps create positive associations with obedience.

Can a dog forget if I yelled at him once?

While dogs may not remember the exact incident of being yelled at, they remember the associated feelings of fear or stress. However, a single event is unlikely to have a lasting impact if it’s not a recurring issue.

Are there laws against yelling at dogs?

Laws vary by location, but most regions don’t specifically have laws against yelling at dogs. However, consistent yelling that causes observable distress or harm may fall under animal cruelty laws.

How can I apologize to my dog for yelling?

While dogs may not understand apologies as humans do, you can show remorse through actions. Spend quality time with your dog, do something they like with them, or offer a special treat. Most importantly, make efforts to prevent future instances of yelling.

Leave a Comment